Brooklyn Pizza & Burgers

Reviews

• Elizabeth L.

  star star star star star 30 July 2026

  This place is AMAZING. We ordered a large pizza, wings, two orders of garlic knots, and a cheese burger.
  Every single thing we ordered was delicious. There were only four of us, but all of the food we ordered was gone in very little time.
  Usually, when a pizza place offers items other than pizza - they're just not good. Not this place. That burger was perfectly seasoned and cooked, two patties both covered in perfectly melted cheese on a toasted bun.
  The wings were crispy and the sauce was spicy and flavorful.
  The garlic knots were gone first. They were beautiful.
  The pizza was truly what you think of when you want a NY style pizza.
  Everything was great. Best pizza delivery option we have!

• Ty B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 30 July 2026

  We live just up the road so we were so excited when we tried this for the first time, but wow was the service bad...we asked what they suggested and when they told us, we were torn; so we asked if they could do half and half so that we would both be happy. To our surprise they said YES! Our card was charged and we sat down. Moments later they informed us that they actually couldn't do it so our whole plan changed. Right after that the soda machine wasn't calibrated so that was no good either. The pizza was good but hard to see how good it is for the price. For the $17 we spent on a medium pizza we could buy 2 larges from other places and be just as satisf.
  
  Tried this place again they charged us for extra sauce even though I said last time there wasn't enough for calzones...

• Javier V.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 26 July 2026

  If you're going to name a pizzeria Brooklyn's pizzeria you have to make chicken rolls. If not Change the name to Suwanee's pizzeria. There are also other items missing from the menu that you would find in a real Brooklyn pizzeria.

• Kim G.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 19 July 2026

  This was the worse pizza I have ever had.  I ordered a Medium meatball & tomato pizza and lemon pepper wings for delivery - was called back saying they were out of mediums??? I had to order a large!  Extremely weird for a pizza place making their own pizza dough??? When it arrived it was bland the crust was cardboard in taste, very little sauce and very little taste.  The "sliced meatballs" were horrible.  I had 1 piece, and threw away the rest.  The wings were dry, crusty, and not good at all - threw those away as well. Would highly recommend to never order from here.

• Nathan W.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 13 July 2026

  Total bummer. We use to love this place then it changed owners and went down the tubes. After several years and seeing some new better reviews we decided to give it another try. Sadly I called 3 times and it went to a full voicemail box each time. Oh well. Back to papa johns I guess.